You've written the page, chosen the images and spent far too long moving things around. Now you need a headline.
“Welcome to our website.”
We can do better than that. Start with what you want the reader to understand. What have they arrived for, and what's worth their attention here?
What are you actually trying to say?
Ask what the reader wants to understand, do or decide. Then write the answer plainly.
A branding page might be about making an expanding business look and sound coherent. A property page might help someone find a home that fits a particular way of living. A report might explain an expensive mistake the reader wants to avoid.
Write that explanation without trying to make it clever. Once the idea is clear, you have something to play with. Searching for impressive words before knowing what you mean is a slow way to produce a very ordinary headline.
Let the context do some of the work
An email subject, a search-result title and a homepage headline are not interchangeable.
An existing customer may understand a reference that means nothing to a stranger. A product page can rely on the product image and surrounding information. A search result has to make sense without the design that accompanies it on your website.
Choose the amount of curiosity the situation can support. A headline that withholds everything may get attention and still leave the wrong people clicking.
I would rather attract someone for the right reason than celebrate a click the page immediately disappoints.
Write alternatives with genuinely different angles
Changing “great” to “exceptional” is not exploring a second idea.
Try a direct outcome, a useful question, a specific observation and a demonstration-led line. For a web-publication service, the directions might be:
“Turn your PDFs into web publications.”
“What happens after someone downloads your whitepaper?”
“Your report shouldn't require thumb gymnastics.”
“Same research. See it on a phone.”
They do different jobs. The first explains the service. The second opens a strategic discussion. The third expresses a familiar frustration. The fourth invites proof.
The thumb-gymnastics line needs a supporting sentence that explains the service, perhaps: “We turn long PDFs into web publications people can read comfortably on a phone.” Without that explanation or a useful demonstration, you've identified an annoyance but left the offer out.
None wins in isolation. Choose according to the audience, the placement and what comes immediately afterwards.
Say which improvement you mean
“Grow your business” could belong to a bank, a bookkeeper or a protein shake with ambition.
Explain the particular improvement. Make the business, task or audience recognisable. Avoid numbers you cannot support and promises the rest of the experience cannot fulfil.
Google may generate a search title from several page signals, not only the title tag. Use a descriptive SEO title and a meaningful visible heading rather than treating either as a container for repeated keywords.1
The body still has to deliver. You cannot headline your way out of an empty article.
Read it aloud, then remove the performance
Would you actually say the line to a customer? Is there a word doing no work? Does the supporting sentence explain the offer, or repeat the headline with more adjectives?
Keep the personality when it helps. Lose it when the reader needs a translation.
Before testing a headline, decide what a better result would mean. Did the right people continue, understand the offer and take a useful next step? When comparing alternatives, keep the offer and destination consistent enough to understand what changed. A different audience landing on a different page tells you very little about which headline did the work.
A headline that attracts fewer but more relevant conversations may be doing a better commercial job. A handful of clicks is a reason to keep looking, not a grand discovery about human behaviour.
Give the reader a reason to continue, then make sure the next paragraph was worth continuing to. That second part is easy to forget while everyone is admiring the headline.