“We offer great service, competitive prices and years of experience.”
Lovely. So does the next company. According to its website, anyway.
Great service matters. But what are you actually promising? Someone who answers the phone? A named person who knows the job? Help sorting out the thing that broke on Friday afternoon? Tell me that. Now I can judge whether it matters to me.
That's what we're doing when we turn features into benefits: getting past the company's description of itself and into the customer's life.
What do you actually do?
A feature is something the product or service has, does or includes. A benefit is what that means for the person using it.
“Great service” is barely even a feature. It is a review you have written about yourself.
What does the service involve? One named contact? Someone answering the phone outside normal office hours? Installation included? Help from the person who built the thing rather than a queue of people asking you to repeat the problem?
Now we have something to work with.
Write down the specifics before trying to make them sound impressive. I can work with a service someone can describe. “Exceptional excellence” gives us rather less to go on.
Ask the two questions that do the work
For each feature, ask:
Why should I care? What’s in it for me?
Take a software company offering a named onboarding contact. That is the feature.
The practical benefit might be that the customer knows who to approach when something is unclear. Go a little further: fewer conversations starting from zero, less coordination and a clearer route to getting the team working with the system.
So instead of “We provide exceptional onboarding support”, try: “Work with one named contact who knows your setup, so you don't have to explain it again every time you need help.” The benefit has a mechanism behind it. A customer can understand the promise and ask whether you deliver it.
Now put yourself in the manager's position. They're going to introduce this system to colleagues. They'll be the person answering questions if it becomes a pain in the arse to use. Knowing there is someone to call may matter quite a lot.
That is worth understanding before deciding that the most impressive feature on your list belongs in the headline.
The same feature will matter differently to a founder implementing their first system and an experienced operations team replacing an established one. Start with a person in a situation, not “businesses of all sizes.”
Don’t throw the features away
“Sell benefits, not features” is useful advice until somebody takes it to mean that details no longer matter.
A customer buying a commercial refrigerator still needs its dimensions, capacity and operating specifications. “Keep your business cool” is not an answer to whether it fits through the bloody door.
Lead with what matters, then give people enough detail to check whether the offer fits. For a service, explain what you're helping them achieve and how the work is done. Let them see the scope and examples. They shouldn't have to take “we make life easier” entirely on faith.
Everyone else saves time too
“Save time” can be a real benefit. It is also a claim made by practically every software company with a homepage.
Ask what creates that saving, whose time it saves and what the customer is currently doing instead. “Stop copying the same order details into three systems” gives us a task to discuss. “Save hours every week” needs evidence of how many hours and under what conditions.
The answer may reveal a useful distinction. It may also reveal that you are selling something fairly ordinary, in which case you need to compete honestly on the complete offer rather than invent uniqueness.
Try finishing this sentence:
For [a specific customer dealing with a specific situation], we provide [the relevant outcome], through [the thing we actually do differently or particularly well].
That is a working sentence, not necessarily your final headline. Its job is to make the thinking clear enough that the headline has something worth saying.
Choose the value worth leading with
You do not need twelve promises above the fold. You need the most useful reason to pay attention, backed by the details that support a decision.
Talk to customers about why they chose you, what nearly stopped them and what became valuable once the work was underway. Compare that with the things you keep promoting. The interesting bit is often the gap.
Put the resulting message into a proposal or a page and ask someone outside the business what they think you're offering. Resist the temptation to explain it for them.
Start with the first claim on your own homepage. Keep asking “Why should I care?” until the answer says more about what the customer gets than how wonderful you think you are.